
“Don’t mess with the sea unless you want it to mess with you back.”
4.5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Johnathan Covey is desperate to escape the small fishing village on the gloomy island Kelcarrow, where he feels increasingly left behind as his friends prepare to leave for college. With no future waiting and no way to follow them, he turns to an old local legend and pays a tithe to Scorpion Deep, an ancient sea god believed to be nothing more than folklore. His wish is granted, but waking something that should have stayed beneath the ocean has a much higher price than he imagined. As Scorpion becomes more and more obsessive, and Johnathan begins to change in terrifying ways, he needs to figure out how to stop it before it consumes him.
“He had always wished he could unwrap words like soft candies and place them directly on their tongues so that he would be understood.”
C.G. Drews did it again, creating the kind of story that is both grotesque and beautiful. Kelcarrow’s setting, a gloomy seaside town with a decaying home, dark ocean, and folklore, created a sense of dread. I love the way the horror of this story ties into Johnathan’s own struggles with loneliness, fear of abandonment, and his desperate need to feel wanted. He is a compelling, messy character. The dynamic between Scorpion, a terrifying sea god and a lonely boy who wants to be chosen was obsessive, possessive, deeply unsettling, and fascinating.
There is a difference between being loved and being wanted, and those things can become confused when you’re desperate.
“It’s madness to love the sea, but at least it loves him back.”
Drews has a distinctive way with words, making the most repulsive descriptions feel lyrical.
The pacing kept me engaged, and there were some moments when I wasn’t sure what was real or where the story was going.
I would have liked more development for Rae and Ellis, as their friendship with Johnathan was an important part of his story, but it felt less fleshed out than his relationship with Scorpion.
I loved the ending and how much room it left for interpretation.
CW: blood gore, child abuse, toxic relationships, suicidal ideation
Thank you Macmillan Children’s Publishing Group for the advanced copy to review!



